Combining Psychology with Experience To Save You Money
Your Native Lancaster, PA Realtor
About Gabe Cicala
The Lancaster Agent Who Knows Every Neighborhood
Gabe Cicala is a licensed real estate agent with Premier Sotheby's International and has been a top producing agent for the last 3 years. Since becoming a full time agent in 2023, Gabe has closed nearly $40,000,000 in residential real estate transactions and sold over 30 homes in 2026.
Whether you're a first-time buyer navigating the fast-moving market of Lititz, a family relocating to Hempfield, or a seller ready to maximize your return on a Lancaster or Manheim property, Gabe brings the local knowledge, negotiation skill, and honest guidance to get you to the closing table with confidence.
Expert Representation for Every Transaction
Whether you're buying your first home or selling an investment property, Gabe brings full-service representation to every client across Lancaster, PA and surrounding.
Buyer Representation
Buying a home in East Petersburg, Columbia, Mountville, or anywhere around Lancaster County is one of the biggest decisions you'll make. Gabe guides buyers through every step, from identifying the right neighborhood to negotiating the final price with honest, pressure-free guidance. First-time buyers, move-up buyers, and out-of-state relocations all welcome. Gabe understands the specifics of the contracts, local laws, and psychology inside and out, enabling him to outwit his competitors with the best negotiation tactics in the industry, which have resulted in deals up to 25% below list price, 18% below appraised value, new roofs at closing, a resource and contact for every need you could think of, and so much more.
Relocation Services
Moving to the Lancaster area from out of state? Gabe specializes in helping relocating families and professionals find the right community, whether that's the convenience of Lititz, the waterfront lifestyle of Columbia, or the quiet of Shaefferstown or Denver. Virtual tours and remote-friendly processes are available, which helped Bo, a client from Hawaii move and close on a home, all from Hawaii, as well as Zhaodeng, who purchased an investment property, all while in China, with a translator I provided.
Seller Representation
Selling your home in Lititz, Manheim, Conestoga, or Millersville requires smart pricing, strong marketing, and a skilled negotiator in your corner. Gabe combines deep local market data with a proven listing strategy to help sellers maximize their return and minimize days on market, which has resulted in contracts within 12 hours of list, highest price per square foot sales in several neighborhoods, $15,000+ buyer credit requests negotiated down to zero, reduced buyer agent commission, and much more.
Agents
Gabe also works with real estate agents across the globe who want to grow their business organically, without relying on paid leads or cold calls. His coaching program shares the exact strategies that made him a top producing broker in his early 20s.
$40,000,000
Total Closed Production
5
Years of Experience
85+
Homes Sold
20+
Years in Lancaster
